Post Thoughts are recurring selections of topics, based on discussions inside the Leighpeele.com forums. The purpose is to elaborate on conversations or threads from the forum. Due to Post Thoughts originating in the forums, they are for members only.
In the research section of the Leighpeele.com forums, a poster alerted me to an article written by Don Matesz. He is an author and self-proclaimed Paleolithic preacher. The article titled “Fiber Fallacies,” discusses fiber and its relationship to our health. An ironic factor is the word “Fallacies” resides in the title. A fallacy is an argument that at first glance may appear logical, but contains fundamental flaws. It is an argument not logically valid. My Post Thoughts is not an attack on Don, I don’t know him, but a critical look at his argument against fiber. It is also a peek at how Paleo dieters provide these fallacy arguments in blind support for their dieting cause.
Don’s Article
To open the article, Don says, “Do you eat vegetables and fruits to get the “benefits” of fiber? You might feel surprised to learn that not one experimental study has proven any beneficial effect or human requirement for fiber. ”
This is because it is nonsensical. There are small amounts of fiber in almost any diet program. Removing fiber removes a balanced diet. The argument makes no sense. Very few diets contain no fiber at all. One point we do know from research is a variety of foods is the best route to go for optimal health.
He also states in his comments section that he was talking about excessive intake of grain, not fruit and vegetables. If this only applies to grains/beans as a whole, why start out your statement referring to fruits and vegetables?
Don Says, “In terms of requirement, facts prove humans do not need fiber in the diet.”
Again, food comes with fiber. A diet prescribed by Paleo man would give way to at least 10-15g of fiber intake if not more with an increase in fruit and vegetable consumption. There are no RDA requirement for fiber but reviews conclude a healthy fiber intake would be around 14g for every 1000/kcal [1]. If you look at this logically, it is a nice basis for a healthy diet. For someone who eating 2000 calories a day, intake would equal 28g of fiber. Continue Reading…